Tesla Model S

The Model S has the longest history of any Tesla, so condition and model year matter enormously. The single most important thing to check on older cars (roughly 2012 to early 2018) is the MCU1 infotainment computer, which used an 8GB eMMC memory chip that wears out and fails. This was the subject of a 2021 NHTSA recall covering about 135,000 Model S and X vehicles; Tesla's remedy replaced the chip, so confirm the recall was completed or that the car already has the newer MCU2. A laggy or dead center screen on an older S is a red flag.

‍

Air suspension is standard on many S trims and is a known maintenance item as cars age. On your test drive, make sure the car raises and lowers correctly and isn't throwing suspension errors, and budget for the possibility of strut or compressor work down the line. Also note the major dividing line of the early-2021 refresh: cars from that point on got a completely new interior with the controversial "yoke" steering wheel (a round wheel became available again from early 2023), a horizontal center screen, and the tri-motor Plaid trim. Pre-2021 cars have a conventional round wheel and a vertical portrait screen.

‍

Battery and drivetrain are generally robust, but very high-mileage early cars can show reduced range and, occasionally, drive-unit replacements (often already done under warranty). Verify any applicable software recalls were applied, including the December 2023 Autopilot driver-monitoring update and the late-2024 rearview-camera fix on certain newer cars. The Model S depreciates heavily, so a well-maintained used example can represent a lot of car for the money, but factor in that out-of-warranty repairs on a flagship are not cheap.

The Model S is Tesla's flagship sedan: the largest, most powerful, and most expensive car in the lineup (the Plaid is among the quickest production cars made). It's the choice for a shopper who wants a full-size luxury EV with maximum range, performance, and presence, and who doesn't need an SUV body.

‍

Compared to the Model 3, the S is in a different class entirely: bigger, faster, more luxurious, with air suspension and a more spacious rear seat, but at a substantially higher price even used. Many shoppers cross-shop a high-mileage used Model S against a newer Model 3, and the answer depends on whether you value size and prestige or lower running costs and newer tech.

‍

Within the lineup, the Model X is the S's SUV counterpart: same flagship tier and powertrains, but with falcon-wing doors, a taller body, and up to three rows of seating. If you want flagship Tesla performance but need to haul people and gear, the X is the natural pick; if you prefer a lower, sleeker sedan, the S is it. The Model Y and Cybertruck sit in more mainstream and specialized niches respectively. For the buyer who wants Tesla's best sedan and is comfortable with flagship repair costs, the Model S stands alone.

‍

Survey feedback from Recurrent's community of EV owners that includes a variety of model years and vehicle trims.